User blog comment:TsurugiFan16/Most Strongest Player V1/@comment-4703969-20120421223345

Tenma vs Taiyou, huh...

Where do I begin...they're similar in ALOT of ways, however, Taiyou is a genius player that only comes once in a decade, great players like Tenma are quite common. Since I'm basing this off the anime, Taiyou Shin Apollo is certainly stronger than Majin Pegasus Arc (it took on Matei Gryphon and almost won, but Majin Pegasus Arc is stronger in the game).

Taiyou could also pass Raimon's defense in the blink of an eye without ANY hissatsu waza, whilst most of the dribbles Tenma has made have been through Soyokaze Step (although, in the game, Tenma has far better dribble).

Taiyou certainly has more stamina and courage. He has more leadership qualities than Tenma as well, not to mention his intelligence (remember how he got through Goseishin Titanias? Truly a genius).

This post could go on for ages, but I'm gonna make this vote as short as I can.

Basically, in-game, I'd say they're about on-level with eachother, but since we're basing it on the anime: My vote goes to Amemiya Taiyou.