User blog comment:TsurugiFan16/Nomination Game/@comment-5883440-20130406205419

Finally got time to debate! Here it is:

Stats

Their Kick and Dribbling stats don't matter for them so I won't explain. They have the exact same Catch stat of 152 which is very impressive. Shuten's Block stat just passes Mecha Endou's by 5 so not much difference there. Shuten may have a higher GP stat but Mecha Endou's TP is greater than his, same goes for technique Mecha Endou's 121 stat defeats Shuten's by 16! Personally I don't think speed is a major factor when it comes to goalkeeping but Shuten's stat is higher. Shuten has a greater stamina stat than Mecha Endou but his Lucky stat surpasses Shuten's by 8 which could be useful in a tricky situation in a match.

Hissatsus

As Torch said below, they have pretty equal hissatsus so there's not much to talk about there. Unfortunately, Mecha Endou's skill Hard Puncher doesn't really give him an advantage unlike Shibire Healing.

Keshin

Mecha Endou has a powerful robot avatar  Eichi no Ou Bunguou and Shuten has  Kyoshin  Gigantes. As Torch stated,  Eichi no Ou Bunguou's skill NEVER GIVE UP puts not just Mecha Endou but the entire team he is on at an advantage.

Anime

Unlike Mecha Endou, Shuten has no importance in the series. He was able to stop a few shots but that's about it. Mecha Endou however had great importance. Without him, El Dorado Team 2 would have been at a HUGE disadvantage without a keeper. According to Sakamaki Toguru Mecha Endou has within him special data that consists of the matches Endou has played which helped to create his hissatsu Penguin The Hand. He also has an insane amount of power which made him short circuit after successfully blocking Dead Future twice! Eventually he sacrificed his life (I know he's a robot and doesn't have an ACTUAL life but you know what I mean...) protecting the goal like Endou never giving up even when the odds are against him.

Overall Shuten may have the upperhand at some times, but Mecha Endou is clearly the stronger goalkeeper.