User blog comment:TsurugiFan16/MSPD: Inazuma Debaters!/@comment-4902411-20130621150718

Okay, so I know I'm a lot late for a debate, but I'll still try. (Even though, I won't be adding the plot part)

Let's take a look at the stats of both. Burn's GP and TP both are better by 3 and 4, even though not massively, but even a little counts. Kick's equal and Burn has a better dribble, by 2. Asta's technique is better, by 2. Asta has a better block by 12. Burn's speed is better, by 2 again. Stamina is in favor for Burn by 7. Catch's better for Asta, by 25, but since it's useless for a FW, I won't count it. Asta's lucky overrules Burn's by 7. As the main stats for a FW are, Kick, Dribbling, Technique and Lucky, GP/TP (Lucky and GP/TP counts for each position) Kick's tied, so nothing could be said. Burn has better Dribble, by 2, Asta has better technique, by 2. Lucky is better for Asta, by 7 and Burn's GP/TP are better by 3/4. If counted everything, both appear almost equal in stats.

From Leo's debate, it is proven that Burn's max Kick stat surpasses Asta's by 16. (Also, if Burn's keshin is counted too, his kick will rise by 15, due to Kick Force.) This pretty much proves that Burn will prove to be a better FW, than Asta. Added to this, Burn's stats allow him to be a better MF than Asta.

Time for the hissatsu part. Firstly, both share Sunshine Storm, so it gets cancelled out. Atomic Flare, TP : 55, along with STAB and Hi no Kokoroe. The element and the skill are surely proven to make the shoot powerful. Dimension Storm, TP : 60. Strong, but let's face it, Atomic Flare would surely get more power with Hi no Kokoroe and the STAB. Spark Edge Dribble, TP : 40, STAB. Asterisk Rock, TP : 40, STAB. Almost equal in respective types. Also, since the effect of crusher is not stated, I cannot say anything about it.

Okay so, Asta has a minor advantage with Asterisk Rock, it's a shoot block. But really, for a FW like him, with such Kick, a dribble hissatsu would have suited him. Anyways, Burn's Atomic Flare counters this, it's also a Shoot Block, in fact, it's a [SH] Shoot Block, better than Asterisk Rock. Spark Edge Dribble proves out to be quite effective for Burn, than Asta and his Asterisk Rock.

Keshin part now. Both the keshins have almost the same KP, but Enma Gazard obtains a better Attack by 10. Bakunetsu Storm is a lot better than Red Prison, better by 40KP. Considerably, Burn's keshin provides him better a better hissatsu and an amazing skill, just what a FW needs. Asta's keshin provides him a moderately strong hissatsu, but when compared to Bakunetsu Storm, it proves out to be really weak.

As already said, I won't be debating based on the plots, since the plot of Asta is not yet known. Until there are definite proofs for the plot of Asta, I would not debate on it, sorry.

Coming to an end, I find Burn to be better FW than Asta, with better stats, better hissatsu and a better keshin.

Feel free to counter debate against anything I've stated in my debate.

"Even I'm a human, I too make mistakes, but I humbly accept them."