User blog comment:TsurugiFan16/Nomination Game/@comment-4485900-20130406042904

Wow, that was quick Dragon XD Then, allow me to back up your debate, using mine:

1/ Stat: Shuten and Mecha Endou has the same Catch stat (152), so they're equal in pure catching strength. Mecha Endou may has higher TP, but Shuten has a higher GP in response. And finally, Shuten has a higher Stamina and a much higher Speed, which will prove very useful for him in any situation. Mecha Endou only has a higher Technique, his high Luck doesn't has much helps here.

2/ Hissatsu: Both Shuten and Mecha Endou's moveset has almost the same level: Penguin The Hand = Sand Cutter (40 TP), God Hand V = Kill Bridge (50 TP). However as Dragon said, Penguin The Hand cause heavy damages to M.Endou's Shibire Gauge while Sand Cutter doesn't. And to make things worse, M.Endou doesn't has Shibire Healing while Shuten does, this will make Shuten has even greater advantages when it comes to Skills and the Shibire gauge. M.Endou's Hard Puncher is indeed useless, since all of his hissatsu are Catch.

3/ Keshin and Mixi Max: First, Shuten's Gigantic Bomb cost 70 KP while M.Endou's Hissou! Gamusharan cost only 50 KP, that's more than enough to see which one is better. And second, M.Endou doesn't has a Best Match M.M while Shuten has 1 with Fadam, and this will make his Catch Stat much higher then usual. Thus, Shuten beat M.Endou completely in this section

To sum it up: Shuten is a better Goalkeeper than M.Endou, with slightly better Stats, a useful Skill, a stronger Keshin, and most of all a Mixi Max advantage.